Skip to main content

Victorian Era (1837-1901) : Meridian School Research Guide: Scholarly vs popular

Characteristics of scholarly journals versus popular magazines


Characteristics

Scholarly

Popular


How can you tell
the difference
between these
two types of
periodicals?

Victorian Literature and Culture is published by the New York University Press

Victoria Magazine is published from Hoffman Media

Victoria Magazine February 1993 Victorian Pincushions Vintage Clothier Cornelia Powell Roses


Length

Longer articles, providing
in-depth analysis of topics

Shorter articles, providing
broader overviews of topics


Authorship

Author usually an expert or specialist in the field, name and credentials always provided

Author usually a staff writer or a journalist, name and credentials often not provided


Language/Audience

Written in the specialized vocabulary of the field for scholarly readers (professors, researchers or students)

Written in non-technical vocabulary for anyone to understand


Format/Structure

Articles usually more structured, may include these sections: abstract, literature review, methodology, results, conclusion, bibliography

Articles do not necessarily follow a specific format or structure


Special Features

Illustrations that support the text, such as tables of statistics, graphs, maps, or photographs

Illustrations with glossy or color photographs, usually for advertising purposes


Editors

Articles usually reviewed and critically evaluated by a board of experts in the field (refereed)

Articles are not evaluated by experts in the field, but by editors on staff


Credits

A bibliography (works cited) and/or footnotes are always provided to document research thoroughly

A bibliography (works cited) is usually not provided, although names of reports or references may be mentioned in the text



 *This table adapted from an original provided courtesy of the University of Texas San Antonio Library

More tips

Many of our databases, including Academic Search Complete, allow you to refine your search to limit results to scholarly (also called peer-reviewed or refereed) articles. Some others, such as JSTOR and Project Muse, contain only scholarly material.
 
Depending on the nature of your research, both scholarly journals and popular magazines can be valuable sources. Your professors will tell you what kinds of sources are acceptable for specific assignments.
 
Examples of a popular and a scholarly article on the Victorian Era:

Popular:  "Great Expectations: The Sons And Daughters Of Charles Dickens." New Yorker 88.39 (2012): 1. 
 
Scholarly:  Wood Cordulack,Shelley. "Victorian Caricature and Classicism: Picturing the London Water Crisis." International Journal of the Classical Tradition , Vol. 9, No. 4 (Spring, 2003): 535-583.
 
If you are unable to find enough information to determine whether a journal is scholarly or not, ask a librarian for help.

Periodicals

"Periodicals" are ongoing publications that come out with new individual issues over time, such as People Weekly, The New York Times, or Journal of American Studies. Each issue of a periodical contains unique articles, which can be identified by using indexes and databases. Periodicals can be generally classified as scholarly journals (also called "peer-reviewed") or non-scholarly. Non-scholarly periodicals include popular and journalistic sources--magazines or newspapers.  

Scholarly journals like Journal of American Studies, popular magazines like People Weekly, and newspapers like The New York Times, each have different editorial processes and it is important to know the clues that will help you distinguish one type of periodical from another so you can use the kinds of sources your professors require you to use for particular assignments. Below is a PDF with a chart that will help.